I recently read two short stories that made me think about my life. The first is the well-known “The Rich Brother” by Tobias Wolff, and the second one is titled “Sonny’s Blues” by James Baldwin. For those who don’t know, both are stories about the struggle between two brothers. In both stories, the older brother is financially successful, with a stable job and a family, while the younger is more of a free spirit, with no money and also no obligations, seeking out the more spiritual side of life. The older brother tries to help the other get on his feet, but the younger brother seems not to care if he does or not, because money and stability are not things that interest him.
The two brothers in these stories have a difficult time understanding each other because while the older brother cannot understand why the younger one just won’t settle down and work like everyone else, the younger brother cannot understand why his older sibling cares so much about money and stability, and how he can be content with just making money and having no purpose in his life.
These stories are so great to me because I think they are both perfect illustrations of what so many of us struggle with. How do we balance out our desire for security with our desire for freedom? To what extent is our happiness or our feeling of meaning in our life at the mercy of our real or perceived obligations? I think that these questions are at the core of every major decision we make in our life.
For some it may be easy to figure out what they want for life, but if you’re like me, you may feel trapped. There are so many questions to be asked, and I have no answers. Or perhaps I have too many. What if I make the wrong decision?
I have this constant battle raging in my head as my desires clash with my responsibilities, and it’s just this big confusing headache that won’t go away. I wonder why I live the life I do… why did I bind myself to this endless routine of class and work and sleep and class and work and sleep… over and over again. Why is it that I’m doing nothing now that I ever wanted to do for my entire life? My whole life has become about responsibility and securing my future, while I feel depressed and unfulfilled, far away from all those that love me, with my back turned on everything I ever cared about because those things aren’t “practical”. Am I so wrapped up in my responsibilities that I’m missing out on something so much better?
I know that money and happiness are not the same, but it’s really not just about money. Its other things. Do I want to get married, have a family and spend most of my life in the same place, or do I want to travel the world, experience new things, and feel freedom? Do I major in something I love, or in something practical? The truth is that I want ALL of these things, but I’m not sure it’s possible.
Maybe it’s just the way I was brought up that leaves me so confused. Living in 18 different houses, going to different schools, having an unconventional family who I love deeply…maybe if I had had a conventional life I wouldn’t have to ask… I’m not sure. I hope though that I can find a balance in my life between what I want and what I need, because we only have one life to live, and I don’t want to miss out. I just keep going back to these stories and thinking… which brother got it right? The obvious choice may be the older brother, but if you look closely you can see his discontent, the kind that comes from a life without meaning.